China is an Imperialist states which defined its current borders by violence. Xinjiang and Tibet did not voluntarily federate with the Chinese State. They were subjugated by force.
China is best compared to Russia.
And the century of humiliation is long gone.
And lest we forget, the most recent Imperialism to face China was Asian. And not Western.
Anarchy worked great in practice, until Franco killed it.
It is worth mentioning that this means it did not work in practice because it was killed! Yes, the same can be said of ML projects like Burkina Faso that were toppled and thereby had very little they were able to pass on in the long term except lessons (Sankara was incredible and his band mate who betrayed him was a bastard). Communes are great when you don’t have capitalist-aligned states who want to destroy you, but currently the state of the world is one where capitalist encirclement is an inevitability.
Anarchy worked great in practice, until Franco killed it.
Removed by mod
Stalin did
Removed by mod
If he really was trying to build communism, then yes.
Removed by mod
Because they both want to achieve communism and fascist taking power (like happen in real life) would suck
Removed by mod
Or stalinists could just not infight
well, maybe I read you wrong then.
I completely agree that imperialistic capitalism is cancer - and USA and China are the current front runners…
Removed by mod
China is an Imperialist states which defined its current borders by violence. Xinjiang and Tibet did not voluntarily federate with the Chinese State. They were subjugated by force.
China is best compared to Russia.
And the century of humiliation is long gone.
And lest we forget, the most recent Imperialism to face China was Asian. And not Western.
It is worth mentioning that this means it did not work in practice because it was killed! Yes, the same can be said of ML projects like Burkina Faso that were toppled and thereby had very little they were able to pass on in the long term except lessons (Sankara was incredible and his band mate who betrayed him was a bastard). Communes are great when you don’t have capitalist-aligned states who want to destroy you, but currently the state of the world is one where capitalist encirclement is an inevitability.